Lincoln
How on earth this utterly dreadful, dire film comes to be up for 12 Oscars
is completely beyond me. It seems that if you make any old rubbish about an
American hero and attach a “Kennedy” tag to it, you will go far.
It is to the "historical dramas" genre what A Quantum Of Solace is to the
"action/adventure" genre. I very much like anything connected with history,
but it has to be made interesting and relevant, it has to have a plot and it
has to have narrative drive. This film was dry in the extreme - it assumed
an expert background knowledge of the events, gave no explanations and just
ploughed on regardless through a sea of molasses of turgid and needless
detail. It was like reading a school textbook from the 1930s, or even
better, watching a live TV broadcast of the parliament of a foreign country
but without any commentary or knowledge of what was going on. More than
anything else it was like old fashioned school teaching of history, rote
learning of dates and the sequence of the kings and queens of England - or
the presidents of the USA - it's enough to put you off history for life.
24.02.13